Share:

HITRUST e1 vs i1 vs r2: Which Assessment Should a HealthTech Company Choose?

Choose the Right HITRUST Assessment

Choose HITRUST Essentials, 1-year (e1) for foundational assurance, HITRUST Implemented, 1-year (i1) for broader security validation, or HITRUST Risk-based, 2-year (r2) for comprehensive, tailored assurance when your risk profile and customer expectations warrant it.

For HealthTech companies, the deciding factors are what hospitals, payers, and other customers will accept, which systems and data are in scope, and how much assurance is appropriate. 

 

Key Takeaways

  • Customer acceptance comes first. Confirm the assessment type and scope expected by procurement teams.
  • Data exposure affects the choice. Protected health information (PHI) sensitivity, system criticality, and vendor dependencies help determine the needed assurance.
  • Assess the actual environment. Certification covers a defined scope, not every product or system a company operates.
  • Check the CSF version. Assessment requirements can change between releases; confirm the applicable baseline before planning control tests.

 

What Are HITRUST e1, i1, and r2 Assessments?

The HITRUST assessment portfolio provides three cybersecurity assurance paths built on the HITRUST CSF:

  • e1 (Essentials): A one-year certification pathway covering a defined baseline of foundational security controls. HITRUST’s e1 introduction describes its intended use.
  • i1 (Implemented): A one-year pathway assessing a broader baseline of implemented cybersecurity practices, informed by current threats.
  • r2 (Risk-based): A two-year pathway whose requirements are tailored to assessment risk factors. Its evaluation encompasses policy, procedures, and control implementation.

Readiness assessments help identify gaps but do not confer certification; validated assessments involve independent testing against selected requirements by a HITRUST Authorized External Assessor and HITRUST quality assurance. Certification follows only when applicable HITRUST requirements are met. These are alternatives, not mandatory stages.

 

HITRUST e1 vs i1 vs r2 

The three HITRUST assessment levels all use the HITRUST CSF, but they differ in depth. HITRUST e1 validates foundational controls, i1 assesses a broader threat-informed baseline, and r2 adds risk-tailored requirements and maturity evaluation. This HITRUST assessment comparison is the quickest way to see where each level fits.

 

Criteria

e1

i1

r2

Purpose

Validate foundational cybersecurity practices

Validate broader, threat-adaptive practices

Provide comprehensive, risk-based assurance

Requirement statements (CSF v11.9)

44

182, including the e1 baseline

The 182 i1 statements plus additional requirements based on risk and scope

Control tailoring

Fixed baseline

Fixed baseline

Tailored to system complexity, sensitive data, and risk factors

Third-party carve-outs

Allowed, if documented

Allowed, if documented

Prohibited

Assurance depth

Scores implemented controls

Scores implementation across threat-informed requirements

Evaluates policy, procedure, implementation, and maturity

Certification validity

12 months

12 months

24 months

Interim assessment

Not required

Not required

Required (see note below)

 

Reading the table: Requirement counts reflect HITRUST CSF v11.9, and earlier versions may differ. Counts alone do not predict effort, because testing depth, the assessed environment, and external service arrangements also affect the work. Confirm your CSF version before scoping.

r2 interim assessment: The standard interim assessment is due within the 90-day window ending on the first certification anniversary. An eligible e1 or i1 assessment can fulfill this requirement.

Version update for e1 and i1: Starting December 31, 2026, MyCSF will no longer allow new e1 or i1 assessments to be created on CSF v11.8. Starting March 31, 2027, unsubmitted e1 and i1 assessments on v11.8 or earlier must be upgraded to v11.9 or later before submission. 

Source: HITRUST advisory HAA 2026-006.

 

What Do These Differences Mean for HealthTech Companies?

Customer acceptance matters. As an illustrative example, one hospital might accept i1 from a vendor while another requires r2. Confirm the requested assurance and certified service before validation begins.

Workload changes with depth. e1 and i1 primarily score control implementation. r2 additionally examines policies and procedures, potentially involving security, engineering, compliance, and management in evidence reviews. Testing effort depends on the actual assessment scope. Teams should also budget time for assessor questions and follow-up testing.

Operational responsibility continues. Assign owners for evidence updates, remediation, and changes that could affect the assessed environment.

Clarify certification boundaries so procurement reviewers know which services were actually included in the independent HITRUST validated assessment.

 

Which HITRUST Assessment Should Your HealthTech Company Choose?

Choose the level that satisfies confirmed customer requirements and matches the assessed service’s risk. HITRUST e1 vs i1 vs r2 is not a ranking by company size. A small vendor may need r2 for a contract; a larger provider may reasonably choose i1 for a particular service.

 

HealthTech situation

Likely starting point

Illustrative example

Early-stage healthcare SaaS with limited complexity

Consider e1, if accepted

A scheduling platform seeks foundational assurance for one application.

Growing SaaS serving several healthcare providers

Consider i1, if accepted

A patient engagement vendor needs broader assurance for implemented controls.

Complex, high-impact healthcare infrastructure

Evaluate r2

An electronic health record (EHR) integration provider supports interconnected clinical workflows.

Hospital or payer specifies a certification

Prioritize the required level

Procurement requires r2 covering a named service.

Existing SOC 2 or ISO 27001 program

Review customer requirements and scope

A cloud vendor can reuse eligible evidence but must satisfy HITRUST requirements.

 

Before scheduling validation, ask procurement to confirm in writing which assessment type it will accept, which service the certification must cover, and when it needs the certificate. For example, if a hospital requires r2 for your patient portal before go-live, record all three details in the assessment plan. 

 

How to Choose: A Five-Step Framework

When requirements conflict, work through these steps in order:

  1. Identify applicable laws. Determine whether HIPAA or other obligations apply independently of HITRUST. Neither certification nor a customer’s preference eliminates legal duties, and the law does not automatically prescribe e1, i1, or r2.
  2. Confirm the customer’s assurance requirement. Preserve the relevant RFP clause or contract language, including the expected assessment type, scope, deliverable, and renewal expectations. Determine whether certification is an absolute procurement condition or a negotiable one. Clarify ambiguous requests for “HITRUST certification,” and ask whether a pending assessment or another form of assurance is temporarily acceptable. Resolve any disagreements between sales, legal, and security before promising certification.
  3. Map your data and the consequences of failure. Trace where PHI enters, moves through, and leaves the application, including APIs and vendor integrations. Then examine clinical dependencies, availability expectations, and potential disruption to care. Handling PHI alone does not automatically require r2; the assessed environment and business impact matter. For a dedicated HIPAA analysis, see Akitra’s HIPAA Compliance Risk Assessment Guide.
  4. Define scope and shared responsibility. Identify the production applications, infrastructure, facilities, and personnel supporting the named service, and confirm the boundary reflects what the customer relies on. Do not assume a certificate covers every product. Document which controls your cloud and service providers perform: e1 and i1 can permit documented carve-outs, while r2 does not permit third-party carve-outs from the underlying assessment. Evaluate available inheritance and external assurance evidence.
  5. Evaluate control maturity and delivery capacity. SOC 2 or ISO 27001 work can reduce preparation effort, but neither automatically satisfies HITRUST requirements, so check whether your existing policies, implementation evidence, and testing records address the selected baseline. Then confirm an executive sponsor and responsible teams can support testing and remediation, with named owners and backups for access reviews, change records, incident documentation, and evidence upkeep between assessor testing periods. If capacity and a customer’s deadline conflict, address the gap rather than choosing an assessment that fails procurement requirements.

Decision rule: Record why the selected level is sufficient, who formally accepted any material assurance gaps, and what future material changes would trigger reassessment.

 

What Should You Confirm Before Starting a HITRUST Assessment?

Turn your decision into three preparation deliverables:

  1. Written scope: Record the agreed assessment type, covered service, and target dates.
  2. System map: Document applications, data flows, infrastructure, and external providers involved in validation.
  3. Evidence plan: Identify control gaps, assign owners, and set remediation deadlines.

Akitra Academy’s HITRUST Certification Course covers assessment preparation and evidence.

 

Can You Progress From e1 to i1 or r2?

Yes. HITRUST uses nested baselines: e1 requirements are included in i1, and i1 requirements form the r2 baseline. Earlier controls and evidence may support a broader assessment, but additional requirements still need validation. Companies can pursue r2 directly. Confirm which evidence can be reused with your assessor.

 

How Akitra Supports HITRUST Assessment Readiness

Akitra Andromeda® helps organize controls and evidence:

  • Policy and Control Management: Centralize control status and responsibilities.
  • Automated Evidence Collection: Gather records from integrated systems.
  • Gap and Remediation Tracking: Identify gaps and coordinate corrective actions.
  • Continuous Control Monitoring: Track changes that may affect readiness.

Akitra does not replace HITRUST validation. Book a Demo to explore the platform.

 

Conclusion: Choose the Assurance Your Business Needs

Choosing between HITRUST e1 vs i1 vs r2 comes down to aligning customer expectations with your organization’s security risks and operational readiness. The most comprehensive assessment is not always the most appropriate.faq

Before committing, confirm the required certification level, assessment scope, and deadline with your customers. This helps ensure your HITRUST efforts deliver meaningful security assurance and support long-term compliance readiness.

 

Security, AI Risk Management, and Compliance with Akitra!

In the competitive landscape of SaaS businesses, trust is paramount amidst data breaches and privacy concerns. Akitra addresses this need with its leading Agentic AI-powered Compliance Automation platform. Our platform empowers customers to prevent sensitive data disclosure and mitigate risks, meeting the expectations of customers and partners in the rapidly evolving landscape of data security and compliance. Through automated evidence collection and continuous monitoring, paired with customizable policies, Akitra ensures organizations are compliance-ready for various frameworks such as SOC 1, SOC 2, HIPAA, GDPR, PCI DSS, ISO 27001, ISO 27701, ISO 27017, ISO 27018, ISO 9001, ISO 13485, ISO 42001, NIST 800-53, NIST 800-171, NIST AI RMF, FedRAMP, CCPA, CMMC, SOX ITGC, and more such as CIS AWS Foundations Benchmark, Australian ISM and Essential Eight etc. In addition, companies can use Akitra’s Risk Management product for overall risk management using quantitative methodologies such as Factorial Analysis of Information Risks (FAIR) and qualitative methods, including NIST-based for your company, Vulnerability Assessment and Pen Testing services, Third Party Vendor Risk Management, Trust Center, and AI-based Automated Questionnaire Response product to streamline and expedite security questionnaire response processes, delivering huge cost savings. Our compliance and security experts provide customized guidance to navigate the end-to-end compliance process confidently. Last but not least, we have also developed a resource hub called Akitra Academy, which offers easy-to-learn short video courses on security, compliance, and related topics of immense significance for today’s fast-growing companies.

Our solution offers substantial time and cost savings, including discounted audit fees, enabling fast and cost-effective compliance certification. Customers achieve continuous compliance as they grow, becoming certified under multiple frameworks through a single automation platform.

Build customer trust. Choose Akitra TODAY!‍To book your FREE DEMO, contact us right here.  

 

Frequently Asked Questions

No. HITRUST e1 certification does not establish HIPAA compliance. HHS says it does not endorse or recognize private certifications under the HIPAA Security Rule, and such certifications do not relieve covered entities of their legal obligations. A business associate must also satisfy applicable HIPAA duties. An e1 assessment can provide useful security assurance, but organizations must separately evaluate their required safeguards and compliance responsibilities.

Check the assessment type, the scope of certification, and the certificate’s validity dates. Confirm that the scope covers the specific product or service your organization plans to use. If the certificate leaves that unclear, ask the vendor for the relevant scope details from its assessment report. .

HITRUST Authorized External Assessor organizations are the only firms allowed to perform validated assessments submitted to HITRUST for certification. HITRUST also has Readiness Licensees, who may provide licensed readiness assessments and advisory services, but not validated assessments unless they are separately authorized as External Assessors. Verify the provider's status in HITRUST's current directory and confirm the engagement's scope before signing.

Missing the r2 interim submission deadline can put your certification at risk. The standard interim assessment must be submitted within the 90-day window ending on the first certification anniversary. HITRUST allows an eligible e1 or i1 assessment to fulfill this requirement. If the deadline is approaching, confirm your options and submission dates with your Authorized External Assessor

Share:

Related Posts

fall g2 badges

Ready to Stop Dreading
Audit Season?

Move to continuous, automated compliance – start with Akitra

fall g2 badges

Ready to Stop Dreading
Audit Season?

Move to continuous, automated compliance – start with Akitra

fall g2 badges

Ready to Stop Dreading
Audit Season?

Move to continuous, automated compliance – start with Akitra

Related Posts

akitra banner image

Elevate Your Knowledge With Akitra Academy’s FREE Online Courses

akitra banner image

Elevate Your Knowledge With Akitra Academy’s FREE Online Courses

akitra banner image

Elevate Your Knowledge With Akitra Academy’s FREE Online Courses

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get the latest tech news, insights and updates from Akitra directly in your inbox.

We respect your privacy. No spam, only valuable updates.

We care about your privacy​
We use cookies to operate this website, improve usability, personalize your experience, and improve our marketing. Your privacy is important to us and we will never sell your data. Privacy Policy.